Skip to content
Agency Sales Routines
Menu

Follow-up routine

Agency sales follow-up that keeps deals moving

Most agency deals are lost after the call, not on it, because the follow-up was late, generic, or missing a next step. This Agency Sales Routines guide gives you the three-part structure Tim Kilroy teaches, a sequence to plan before the call, and a way to help your champion sell you internally.

Published by Tim KilroyLast updated: November 2026

What should I send after an agency sales call?

Send a same-day email that recaps what the prospect said, ties your offer to their situation, and names one specific next step. That is the whole structure. Tim Kilroy calls the follow-up part of the delivery: if you would not half-do the work, do not half-do the email that comes after the call.

The three parts of every follow-up

  1. Part 1

    Recap

    Reflect back their goals, pain points, and words. Not your pitch. This proves you were listening rather than waiting to talk.

  2. Part 2

    Relevance

    Tie your offer to their specific situation. Do not resell. Show the alignment between what they said and how you work.

  3. Part 3

    Next step

    Name one specific action and date that moves the prospect past whatever friction sits between interested and yes.

Definition: agency sales follow-up

On Agency Sales Routines, agency sales follow-up is the planned sequence of messages and meetings between a first conversation and a decision. Its job is to reinforce trust, show you understood, and guide the prospect through the friction between interested and yes.

It is a stage of the sales process, not a bolt-on you do when you remember. A good follow-up recaps the prospect's words rather than your pitch. A weak one says just checking in and quietly undoes the trust built on the call.

Follow-up figures Tim Kilroy cites

of sales require 5 or more follow-ups after the first meeting
80%
of salespeople give up after one follow-up attempt
44%
of sales go to the vendor that responds first
35 to 50%
more likely to close with personalized follow-up than generic templates
3x

As published in Tim Kilroy's Agency Sales Follow-Up Playbook.

How many times should I follow up with a prospect?

Plan for five or more touches, each one useful on its own. The figures above suggest most deals need that many, while many sellers stop after one. Decide the sequence before the call so you are not improvising after the silence starts.

  1. Same dayThree-part recap: their words, relevance, one next step with a date.
  2. Before the next meetingSomething useful tied to a problem they named, such as a short example or a question you thought of later.
  3. After the proposalA forwardable summary your champion can send to the decision maker.
  4. If it goes quietA direct question about status, not a generic check-in. Ask whether the problem is still a priority.
  5. FinalA respectful close-the-loop note that makes it easy to say not now.

Generic versus useful follow-up

Agency Sales Routines: what changes when follow-up uses the three parts
ElementGeneric follow-upThree-part follow-up
OpeningJust checking inYou mentioned your team is losing time to sales
BodyRestates your servicesConnects one part of how you work to their stated problem
AskLet me know if you have questionsA specific next step with a date
TimingWhenever you rememberSame day, then a planned sequence

Help your champion sell you to their boss

Your contact may like you and still not be the person who signs. Give them a short summary they can forward without editing: the problem in their words, the outcome you will create, scope, price, and timeline. If they cannot explain your proposal to their boss in a few sentences, the deal stalls in a meeting you are not in. The three-part email template is on the templates page, and proposal rules are in the closing guide.

How we chose what goes in this guide

The three-part structure and the cited follow-up figures come from Tim Kilroy's published follow-up playbook; the figures are presented as he cites them, not as Agency Sales Routines research. The sequence and comparison table are Agency Sales Routines guidance.

Written and published by Tim Kilroy. Read the full methodology.

Questions agency founders ask

Short answers here. All 44 questions live in the full FAQ.

How many follow-ups does it take to close a deal?

Often more than most agencies send. Tim Kilroy's Follow-Up Playbook cites figures showing that 80 percent of sales require five or more follow-ups after the first meeting, while 44 percent of salespeople give up after one attempt. The practical takeaway is to plan a sequence of useful follow-ups in advance instead of improvising a single check-in.

Open in the FAQ: How many follow-ups does it take to close a deal?

What should a follow-up email include after a sales call?

A strong follow-up includes a recap of what the prospect said, a clear link between your offer and their situation, and a next step that helps them past whatever is slowing the decision. Tim Kilroy's playbook calls the first two parts Recap and Relevance. Recap their words, not your pitch, and skip the generic just-checking-in note.

Open in the FAQ: What should a follow-up email include after a sales call?

Why do prospects go quiet after a great sales call?

Usually because the follow-up was late, generic, or missing a clear next step. Tim Kilroy's view is that most agency sales are lost after the call rather than on it. A same-day recap in the prospect's own words, tied to their situation, with a specific next step, protects the trust you built during the conversation.

Open in the FAQ: Why do prospects go quiet after a great sales call?

What if my prospect likes us but has to sell us to their boss?

Equip your champion to sell for you. Send a short written summary they can forward: the problem in their words, the outcome you will create, the scope, the price, and the decision timeline. If your contact cannot explain your proposal to their boss in a few sentences, the deal will stall in a meeting you are not in.

Open in the FAQ: What if my prospect likes us but has to sell us to their boss?

What is the 3 3 3 rule in sales?

There is no single agreed definition of the 3 3 3 rule in sales; different trainers use the name for different habits, such as three touches across three channels or three questions before three minutes of pitching. Treat it as a memory aid rather than a standard. What matters more is a defined follow-up sequence your whole team uses the same way.

Open in the FAQ: What is the 3 3 3 rule in sales?
Read all 44 agency sales process questions

Back to the sales process consulting guide for agency founders